Andrew married Marietta Rice on 16 Mar 1858 in Avoca, Steuben New York, USA. Marietta (daughter of Henry Rice and Eliza Smith) was born on 10 Dec 1837 in Howard, Stueben, New York, USA; died on 3 Mar 1921 in Avoca, Stueben, New York, USA; was buried in Bath, Stueben, New York, USA. [Group Sheet] [Family Chart]

1. Franklin Orlando Gay was born on 8 Mar 1861 in Pulteney, Steuben, New York, USA; died on 23 Jul 1943 in Bath, Steuben, New York, USA.
2. Benjamin Raymond Gay was born on 20 Aug 1865 in Bath, Steuben, New York, USA; died on 29 Jun 1940; was buried in Mount Pleasant Cemetery, Howard, Steuben, New York, USA.