| 1. Vernon Sylvester Fay, b. 15 Oct 1860 d. 23 Dec 1943 (Age 83 years) |
| 2. Winfield Fay, b. 9 May 1862 |
| 3. Donald M. Fay, b. 23 Sep 1863 |
| 4. Dayton Marshall Fay, b. 7 Jul 1865 |
| 5. Erwin A. Fay, b. 16 Jun 1867 d. 19 Aug 1878 (Age 11 years) |
| 6. Carolyn E. Fay, b. 19 Jan 1869 d. 8 Jul 1951 (Age 82 years) |
| 7. Bertha Fay, b. 10 Apr 1871 |
| 8. Etta M. Fay, b. 18 Apr 1872 |
| 9. Leula L. Fay, b. 7 Oct 1873 |
| 10. Anita L. Fay, b. 15 Jan 1876 |
| 11. Flora Fay, b. 19 Apr 1878 d. 16 May 1878 (Age 0 years) |
| 12. Gary Hiram Fay, b. 7 Aug 1880 |